The Cliff Diving Theorem
It wasn’t planned to relocate the party to my apartment. But when the bar closed, no one wanted to go home. I offered my place since it was only a stone’s throw from the Place de la Contrescarpe. I entered first and threw all my dirty laundry in its designated basket, before emptying the ash tray and opening the big window towards Rue Lhomond with a stunning view of the Panthéon. It didn’t seem to bother my guests that my apartment was neither large nor bright. Earlier in the bar the idea of inviting half a dozen of my academic colleagues seemed reasonable, now I wasn’t so sure about it anymore. Maybe it was because I had too much champagne. But we had such a good time and the thought of going home into my lonely and empty apartment seemed even worse. I never bothered to make a home of my flat. Maybe because I knew I would never stay here for too long. However, since then two years passed and I’m still in Paris.
I went into the kitchen and fetched a bowl of nuts and crisps before putting it down on the coffee table in the living room. After that I distributed my last beer bottles and uncorked a fifteen-year-old wine that I bought during my last visit to the Provence. I bought it right after I first arrived in France and buying such a noble wine made me feel like an adult, that I forgot that I don’t really like wine. I never lost a thought over the old bottle until now, when I was finally able to get rid of it. My guests were happy about it, poured themselves generous glasses and toasted to a great evening.
“To the revolution”, said Etienne, a professor for modern French literature who annoys everyone with his passion for the French Revolution and who doesn’t really seem to fit into out circle of historians and archeologists. Some people smile with pity and toast to Etienne, others ignore him and continue their conversations.
With empty hands I join two women from my chair who have dull conversations about ancient Greek philosophy that other people in other times already had. I nod in the right moments and keep quiet when I don’t agree.
“I’m just saying that Homer was the first to depict the two as lovers in the Ilias”, Naïs said but was promptly interrupted by Marion.
“No, it wasn’t Homer, it was Aristoteles.” My colleagues who are both significantly older than I am look at me, expecting me to solve their disagreement.
“Neither is correct. Achilles and Patroclus were never explicitly named as lovers by Homer and by Aristoteles even less. They were said to have a relationship in other literature though mostly in works by Aischylos and Platon.”
“Platon! Obviously. Dieu que je suis bête”, Marion said and clapped her hands over her head.
“Have you ever worked on that topic before Marley?”, Naïs asked me.
“Yes, paederasty was the first topic I worked on here in Paris and the reason why I moved here.”
“And what do you work on now?”
I don’t really like talking about my work in my free time. There used to be a time when I could talk about it without catching my breath but now it almost feels suffocating to just think about ancient Greece. It used to be the only life that mattered to me but I don’t feel the same excitement for it anymore. Maybe that’s the reason why I’m still in Paris, because I don’t know where else to go. Is twenty-eight to early for a mid-life crisis?
My thoughts got interrupted when my guest suddenly all stormed to the window.
“Qu’est-ce qu’il y a?” What is there, Marion asked and squeezed between a professor for archelogy and his wife. I stretched my neck to get a glimpse of the faintly lit street. The street lamp threw a spherical shaped light beam onto the sidewalk and served as a spotlight for an old busker. The old man played all by himself, unaware of his audience on the sixth floor. The steel strings of his guitar gently swung between his nimble fingers, reviving the quiet street corner of the Rue des Irlandais. I instantly recognized the melody. A fourteen-year-old song by Sufjan Stevens, which I haven’t heard in years. But still. The melody transferred me directly into another time. I pushed through my colleagues completely hypnotized by the man downstairs who lived in his own small world and sang like there was no tomorrow.
Suddenly I felt your shadow in the room. Your presence lingered above our heads while the soft notes of the song fade away in the cold Parisian night air. How long has it been that I haven’t thought about that song? Or about you?
Everyone else stepped away from the window again and reengaged in their conversations. I however, was frozen in place, starring at the place where the man just played his guitar. He disappeared and I asked myself if he was ever really there or just a fragment of my imagination. Have I evoked the busker by my suppressed thoughts about you? I wished he was still there so that I could ask him to play the song again. A breeze touched my hair and I was surprised by how cold it already was considering it was only October. Was it a coincidence that we also met in October? This small little town in Northern Ireland that rarely sees any tourists and yet the both of us got lost there at the same time. It’s hard not to think about destiny in moments like this.
----
I was just finished with my bachelor thesis, and I decided to travel trough Northern Ireland without my phone. I noticed you early on. You were sitting in a café, looking out onto the sea, a cup of tea in front of you. Judging by the color I thought it was black tea. But you only drank it after you added two teaspoons of sugar and a dash of milk. I didn’t mean to study you, but your sight captivated me.
After a while you paid, shouldered your backpack, and walked away. As you disappeared in between the houses of the strange city I let you go, and my thoughts wandered on. At that time, I couldn’t suspect that we would meet again. Thank God you talked to me the next time.
It was the following day and I haven’t forgotten your face yet. How could I? I was participating in a lecture that was actually the reason for my stay in this particular city. It was the lecture that awoke my love for ancient Greece. As I was leaving the tiny campus, I saw you walking in front of me and it felt like I was meeting someone from another life.
“You should think that after all those years, ancient Greece should no longer hold any secrets”, you said. Your smile marked my heart like a stigma.
“We only repeat thoughts of other researchers”, I replied and made you smile even more. It felt like making you smile was my mission all along. My life was leading up to this point and I succeeded in my purpose of making you light up. I would fight dragons just to see you smile again.
“How come someone like you is interested in such a topic?”, you asked me.
“Someone like me?”
Again, you smiled.
“Someone who is so young. Someone who should be more interested in parties than the poetry of the epic cycle.”
“I don’t like parties.”
You didn’t either I found out.
We were the last ones to leave campus and we both lowered our pace to avoid the danger of having to part ways.
“Why are you interested in the topic?”, I asked then.
“Someone like me?”, you echoed. I loved talking to you. It was without restriction, rules or fear of saying something stupid. You just seemed very forbearing in that matter.
“Someone so open and brave shouldn’t be interested in a science whose base are statues with chopped of noses.”
“Why do you think I’m open and brave?”
“You talked to me”, I replied.
“I wanted to see you again”, you said smiling answering my first question.
When we reached the inevitable crossroads, we stopped. In that café you observed me the same way I observed you. I asked you for your name and you told me the letters that ever since then haunted me in the middle of the night. Every time it is quiet and dark outside, the city sleeps and I hear nothing but my own breathing, I hear your name.
“Charlie”, you said. So simple, so ordinary but still the root of all my sleepless nights.
“What’s your name?”
“Marley.”
You loved how our names rhymed.
“Marley, do you want to grab a coffee?” I loved how you used my name instantly as if you couldn’t wait to test how it sounded coming out of your mouth.
We were sitting together at the same table you were sitting at alone the day before. You told me you came from London, just like me.
“So we live our whole life in the same city but we meet in a small town in Northern Ireland?”, you asked smiling about the arbitrariness of things.
“Maybe we would not have liked the people we are in the city”, I said.
“I can’t imagine a place where I don’t like you”, you replied. You were so familiar to me, talking with you seemed as easy as breathing.
“Tell me Charlie, where are you headed next?”
“Belfast. I have to handle a couple of things there but after that I’m travelling to Portballintrae. There is a little guesthouse directly at the coast and I won’t be doing anything rather than eating fresh fish, drink black tea and think for days. Do you want to come with me?”
I agreed, extending my journey indefinitely to spend time with you in solitude and become less solitary.
---
“Marley?”, someone suddenly asked and tore me away from my thoughts. I turned away from the window and saw the concerned look on Naïs face. I blinked away a lonely tear at the corner of my eye and faked a smile which almost looked sincere. And suddenly I wanted all my colleagues out of my apartment. Their presence was unbearable for me and all I wanted was to be alone. But how could I get rid of a bunch of intellectual night crawlers without offending them?
“Marley, there you are. I wanted to tell you about the French revolutionary who always quoted Aischylos. I instantly thought about you when I read about it”, Etienne said and put his arm around me.
The literature professor is in his forties but judging by his clothes he could easily be thirty years older. He smelled like menthol cigarettes, alcohol and a sweet aftershave that brought tears to my eyes.
“Another time Etienne”, I said friendly and tried to shake off his arm. There is no space in my head but for the lines from the song I just heard and that reminds me so much of our time in Portballintrae.
“In the morning through the window shade.
When the light pressed up against your shoulder blade,
I could see what you were reading.”
“Etienne, laissez la fille”, Marion said and saved me from my overbearing colleague.
“It’s late, maybe we should go.” I could hug and kiss Marion from gratitude. It didn’t take long until the last one left my flat with kisses and nice words and I was alone again.
Without the abundance of professors, my apartment seemed even smaller. I went over to the cabinet in my living room, took out a bottle of whiskey and a glass. Bushmill Whiskey, the same we drank in the small guesthouse in Northern Ireland. I swirl the caramel-colored liquid around in its glass before swallowing everything like a shot. My throat burns and the alcohol warms my insides. I felt like I time travelled. Back to those days when everything was still new and exciting but at the same time so familiar. It was like I knew you my whole life.
---
The B&B you took me to lay lonesome and deserted on a cliff that was more like a little hill. The next village was miles away and I asked if the guesthouse even gets enough visitors to survive.
“You won’t believe how many people actually come here. It’s the perfect place for an unplanned break”, you explained. It was your first time here as well but you knew the place form a friend you never mentioned again after that.
Inside an old woman greeted us with a cup of black tea and a room key. We sat in front of the crackling chimney fire while the woman, who introduced herself as Daphne, fetched a second room key. After all, she wasn’t expecting you to bring someone. Daphne was an angle in human for and our guardian angle form then on. She did everything for us, whether it was picking us up from a pub in the middle of the night or making additional eggs at breakfast. It was also her who told us about the pub in the neighboring village that had live music that evening.
You told me you couldn’t dance but I made you anyways. When our song was played, we got back to our seats, exhausted and listened to the singer gently playing the guitar.
“This is one of those nights, where we tell each other our biggest dreams and our scariest thoughts”, you told me without looking at me.
“How do you know tonight is such a night?”, I asked. I have never once told anyone my biggest dreams and my scariest thoughts. But you Charlie, I would still tell everything to you. And that’s the way I felt back then. I already answered the question for myself when you provided me with your explanation.
“You and I and the uncertainty that surrounds us. I don’t really know who you are but I got this voice inside of the that tells me that, while drinking Bushmill Whiskey and listening to old cover songs, I can tell you everything.”
We talked the whole night through. The singer ended her set, guests came and left again, and the owner waited impatiently to ring the last-order bell. I looked deep into your eyes until you knew everything about me. You made me say things, I didn’t even know about myself. I told you about my family, how ever broken it was. You told me about your work at a museum in London, restoring old paintings. We talked about our childhood, our teenage years and all the uncertain years in between. I loved how your eyes shimmered when you were excited about something and how you always leaned slightly towards me when I talked.
“Now do you understand what I mean?”, you asked as the sun was rising. Yes. This was one of those nights where you talk about your dreams and your scariest thoughts. At that point in time, I however didn’t know that every night with you, was one of those nights.
---
Two glasses of whiskey later I tried to sleep in my unmade bed. But I was way too restless. How was it possible that after so many months in which I felt OK, I can’t bare the thought of you tonight? Just one song and I’m back in Northern Ireland, I feel the cold breeze, the wind in my hair and you. How you laid next to me for the first time.
I toss and turn but I can’t shake the feeling of your ghost being next to me. The moon shines in my face and I decide to give up trying to sleep. I throw my brown coat over my pyjamas, put on my worn-out sneakers and leave my apartment on the Rue Lhomond. I walk past the bars that merely hours before were full of people and laughter but now lay empty and deserted on the side of the road. The city of love is quiet at this time and I can only hear the traffic from far away. I walk past the famous Panthéon for whose beauty I don’t have time for today, until I reach the Pont de l'Archevêché which stretches over the Saine. The bridge itself is absolutely no architectural highlight, it is however famous for the many locks of lovers that adorn the railing. A long time ago you could admire Notre Dame from this spot but today, the half-burned church is covered and is eagerly awaiting its renovation. Nevertheless I stop on the bridge and watch the river flowing under me.
---
It reminds me of how we both stared into the abyss close to Portballintrae. It was the last day of our journey and we decided to hike along the cliffs not far from the B&B. At one of the most beautiful viewing points you stopped and looked down. I was sacred to get too close to the chasm but you reached out your hand and I couldn’t resist taking it.
“Have you ever thought about how it would be to jump?”, you asked me.
“If you jump, I jump”, I replied.
“Even if we don’t hit the ground together?”
“Would you rather risk it and not jump?”, I asked and we both knew we weren’t talking about the cliff.
Ultimately it was Daphne who gave us the last push. We arrived back at the B&B, tired and exhausted. Daphne was waiting for us with two steaming cups to tea and blister plasters. “My late husband and I always used to hike on that path”, she told us and sat down in one of the oversized wingchairs. Longingly she looked out of the window and sighed.
“I wished we would have used our time together better when we were your age, knowing now how little time we had together.” We looked at Daphne, not sure what to say. This poor old women with her thin hair and her self-knitted jumper. I knew she was right. I didn’t want to waste any time with you so that night we both took the jump. Two years long, until that phone call from Paris.
Daphne became that kind of person we would send Christmas cards to, even though we weren’t the type of people the send Christmas cards. You always said we were too young for that. But Daphne was our good luck charm and we wanted her to know how important she was to us and we didn’t want her to forget us. Just like we would never forget that week in Portballintrae.
---
I was crossing the bridge and found myself in the Île de la Cité. I rarely leave the fifth Arrondissement and feel like a tourist that sees the streets of Paris for the first time. For the first time I can feel their magic. Maybe because of my melancholy, maybe because everything is so peaceful, maybe because it’s the first time I allow myself to open my eyes for this beautiful city that made me hit the ground.
---
“I just got a call from the Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne. They read my thesis in epigraphy about the Peloponnesian war and they are offering me a position”, I told you when I came into the kitchen. You were happy for me but I could see the shadows in your eyes. The ground was coming closer. What followed were long conversations, discussions and fights and lastly the inevitable collision. Just like you suspected back then, miles apart from each other. I packed my bags and left our little apartment behind.
“I wish I never jumped”, you yelled after me and shut the door with a bang. I was never angry at you, you were never to blame. And even when you started hating me, I never stopped loving you.
---
After an hour of straying around, I reach my apartment with the rising sun. My feet hurt, my throat is dry and I’m freezing. I throw my keys onto my shelf carelessly and walk towards my kitchen when I realize a small red light blinking in the corner. I stop in my tracks and notice my answering machine that looks even older than the digs from my workplace. Who on earth would call me on my landline and then leave a message? I don’t even know how to use the damn thing; it came with the apartment. Eventually I push the right button and after a short rustling your voice fills my hallway.
“Hey Marley, it’s me Charlie. I just wanted to talk to you real quick but I guess you’re still sleeping. A loud sob escapes my throat, and the sound of your voice sucks the air of the apartment. “Anyways, I wanted to let you know that Daphne passed away yesterday. I couldn’t sleep all night and I don’t even know why I dialed your number. I guess I just wanted to hear your voice. Daphne has always been our fairy godmother and now that she’s gone, I feel like the last piece that was still holding us together is gone too.” There is a short pause which gives me time to catch my breath but the knot in my chest is getting tighter by the minute. “Gosh, I don’t know what I’m saying. I just wanted to let you know. Sorry if my call disturbed you.”
And then I only heard silence. Now I know that in this miserable and long night, you were thinking about me too. Maybe our thoughts crossed paths in the universe and got tangled together so that we both had to stay awake until one of us went to bed but neither wanted to break off the connection. I’m angry at myself for not being at home when you called. I would have loved to talk to you. I would have loved to tell you about the busker and the many coincidences that have shaped out relationship from the beginning. And just then I realize what you told me on the phone. Poor, old Daphne is finally reunited with her husband.
After our vacation I only saw Daphne once. She inherited an old painting and wanted to know your opinion on it. Was it valuable or just some scribbles of an old relative. We spend another week at her B&B shortly before I left for Paris.
I wonder how the world will look like without the kind-heartedness of that woman. The cocktail of emotions that was being prepared in my head all night long is now finally ready to be served and as I sit down on the couch, I finally start to cry. Tears of grief, melancholy, and longing. I cry because of Daphne; I cry because I feel miserable, and I cry about our future that I threw away for my career. One day we’ll be just like Achilles and Patroclus. People won’t know if we were really lovers, and our relationship won’t be the thing people remember us for.
I watch the sunrise in the east over the Jardin des Plantes and finish my long-awaited coffee. Suddenly I feel a sense of spontaneity I last felt when I first met you. I call Marion to tell her I need a couple of days off. I answer her concerned question if everything is okay with a short ‘oui’ and end the call. I last used my suitcase for a research trip to Turkey, which was over a year ago. I almost never leave Paris. I’m married to my work. But who knows maybe one day I can leave the only place on earth where it wasn’t possible for you to love me.
Now however, I set my sails for Portballintrae. I have to see it with my own eyes, how the world up there looks like without Daphne’s little guesthouse. I have to close that chapter of my life and move on.
I throw all the necessary things into my suitcase and then call Etienne because he’s the only one I know who has a car and a drivers license for that matter. My first thought was to take the Metro to the airport but even with the traffic in the city, I think I’ll be faster if Etienne drives. Besides, I’ll be doing him a favor because he can tell me all about the French revolutionary who quoted Greek philosophers.
Etienne picks me up an hour later without asking questions. For the first time I’m happy about him talking the whole time because it distracts me. Just like back in the day, I don’t know what to expect from my journey to Northern Ireland nor what I actually want from it. At the gate and during the flight, I start to worry more and more so that I almost turn around again during my transfer in Dublin. But the bus to Belfast arrives in less than 30 minutes and the next flight to Paris Charles de Gaulle is in the evening. So, for time management reasons I decide to go ahead with my plan and arrive in Portballintrae before the sun sets.
The small town with around 700 inhabitants is almost deserted during autumn. I walk the last mile to the edge of town, when I see Daphne’s B&B in front of me.
“Sorry, we’re closed”, a man who just came out of the house, tells me as he sees me.
“I’m here for Daphne. I heard what happened and I am so sorry”, I reply. The man lowers his gaze.
“Thank you. Did you know my mother well?”, the man asks me.
“I was here as a guest twice, but we often wrote letters and cards. The contact however died down in the last two years. I’m Marley Foster by the way.”
“Right! I knew I recognized your face from somewhere. Your picture is on my mother’s fridge. Come in please.”
Daphne’s son opens the door wider for me and the tension in my shoulders is fading away when I recognize the familiar smell of lilies inside. My room is a different one than usually, with a view of the neighboring house, which doesn’t seem to be inhabited.
I sleep through the night, curled up in a ball, the blanket over my head. I get up in the early morning hours, change my sneakers for some boots, throw on a raincoat and leave the house. It’s not raining yet but I know better than to trust the Irish weather. The clouds are looking sad and dark as if they’re about to cry the next second. I go on a walk down the road and up the cliffs until the path ends in grass. I look down to my left and see the waves crashing against the shore, loud and wild as if to show they are as strong as their opponent.
Suddenly I hear steps behind me and the next second you’re standing next to me, offering me a cup of tea. As if nothing has changed, you’re standing next to me. You didn’t change much. Your hair is longer and your face sterner. I take a sip from the warming tea because I’m already freezing.
“That’s not black tea”, I say looking down into the cup.
“I know. I don’t drink that anymore. It's called Italian Camomilla Vanilla”, you reply. I try to hide my smile because I have to think about how much you like things that rhyme. You come a step closer, and I can feel your eyes on me. Have I changed at all?
“I didn’t know you would be coming here as well”, you say.
“Me neither. But like you said this is the perfect place for an unexpected holiday.” You just nod and I’m sure you can’t remember our conversation.
“How’s Paris? How is your work?”, you ask straightforward. I can barely recognize your voice. It’s deeper and not as familiar as it used to be. Is that the voice you use with strangers?
“Can we please not do that?”, I ask tortured.
“Do what?” “Pretend that we’re friends. Talk about this or that but not about the important things.”
“I can only offer you to talk about this or that.” I can’t answer anymore and instead redirect my gaze towards the sea and the endless horizon how the two different blue tones melt together.
“We inherited something from Daphne”, you tell eventually and break the silence that has been hanging between us. Years ago, we could sit together in silence for so long without anyone of us feeling the need to say something.
“Come on. I show you.”
I follow you with the still full cup of Italian Camomilla Vanilla tea that I don’t want to drink because it doesn’t taste like you. You lead me to the living room where there is a huge oil painting in a stucco frame on the opposite wall. It’s the painting Daphne wanted your opinion on a while ago. You said it wasn’t valuable, but you liked it anyways and so Daphne kept it.
“Why did she hand it down to the both of us?”, I ask while were standing in front of the gigantic painting. It shows Casimir Pulaski in Nantes sitting on a suitcase, shortly before his departure for America. It is called ‘The Best is yet to Come’.
“I guess we never told her we’re not together anymore.” How easy it is for you to say those words. On the other hand, you had two years preparing to say it, while I was just focusing on my work.
“You can have it if you want”, I say. You look at me with big eyes and it’s only then that I realize you have been crying.
“I don’t want it”, you reply. Your words feel like a dagger going through my chest. I know you don’t want it because it reminds you of me, of us. You turn around and disappear in the kitchen while I’m left with an enormous oil painting from 1871, which shows a polish-American general from the American revolutionary war. Taking that thing with me to Paris could be a problem.
I follow you into the kitchen and get rid of my tea in the sink. I pass Daphne’s fridge which is littered with postcards and pictures. I recognize some of our cards and pictures. One from our first visit here, arm in arm. Our birthday and Christmas cards. Picture of us in our favorite bar in London and a picture of us from our trip to Athens. Both in shorts, with sun-kissed skin and our hats covering our eyes. We look happy. I turn around to you and see how you’re watching me. Trying to figure me out.
“You want to pretend we’re strangers? Then tell my why you’re in Paris.” Your eyes are ice cold, and I can’t see the person from the fridge in you anymore. I put down my cup, which gives me time to choose my words carefully.
“It was a once in a lifetime opportunity. I would have never found such a good job in London.”
“That’s what you said when you left. But I don’t believe you. I think you were scared because for the first time in your life, everything was fine, and you were sure that that wasn’t possible.
So, you pulled the rip cord before you could hit the ground.”
My first instinct is to defend myself but then I realize that you’re right. We didn’t hit the ground together. I used my parachute and didn’t tell you beforehand. My whole theory about our cliff is wrong and I feel like a fraud. I never apologized because I never saw what I did wrong.
You turn around and want to leave the room because you think me not saying anything is because I don’t understand you.
“I thought about you every day”, I tell you before you can leave. You turn to me again, but your arms are crossed before your chest.
“Why?”, you ask squinting at me as if I were a riddle that needs to be solved.
“Because I couldn’t forget you. I didn’t want to forget you. Charlie, please forgive me. I never realized how horrible I was towards you. I will never be able to let go if you don’t forgive me.”
You let go of your arms and your face relaxes so that you almost look like the person again, that’s been haunting my dreams.
“I forgave you a long time ago, but you also have to forgive yourself. To see how hard all of this is for you, makes me believe you.” You want to leave again but you turn around on one last thought. “I know a tiny museum in London that would be interested to have the painting.”
I agree on donating it to the gallery. I like the idea of a part of us hanging in a museum. It’s an ending to our story, the finality of our story. We are going to live where great treasure of the past can find a new home. Our relationship is such a relict. Just like Achilles we too found our end because of Paris. But it seems like I have to go back to London soon to see Daphne’s old painting in an ever-older exhibition and I feel like the circle if finally closing.