Track 6 - Sara (We Three)
Or the Time I Failed
This is the longest essay in this chronicle and whoever knows the song may already know what this is about. But to those who are unfamiliar with the song, I want to issue a trigger warning for suicidal ideation.
What do you do when you feel lonely and agitated by everyone around you? Right, you move out. My stepfather moved to southern Germany from Berlin and sometimes his children come to visit. Since our apartment is too small to inhabit all six of us, he has rented a second apartment in our house. A small two bedroom, souterrain flat that was mostly empty apart from when my mum and my stepdad wanted to watch different TV programs, or his kids came to visit.
In the spring of 2022 I was almost done with my studies. I had spent the last semester at uni and regained some of my personal freedom and also some optimism. I had secured an internship in London that I would begin in August, so the dream of England was back on track two years after its first cancellation. But I had to write my bachelor thesis before that and because I could do that from home, we gave up my dorm room and I moved back home to save money. Going from living alone to living at home to being on your own again and then having to move back home again is difficult. I have developed my own rhythm of living and I wasn’t fitting into my family’s rhythm anymore. We fought a lot about cleaning, eating together, our different sleep schedules and so, after just a few weeks back home, I asked if I could move into the smaller apartment downstairs. My mum and stepdad agreed, and I packed up my clothes, my laptop, and my study documents and settled downstairs.
My sister spent a lot of time with me downstairs but in the end the move was a terrible idea. Most of the time I wrote my bachelor thesis but when I completed it, it was back to my phone and no one to distract me from it. I sometimes went days without seeing anyone and without leaving the flat. I oftentimes went upstairs to eat but sometimes I also cooked for myself and then I had no reason to see my family.
This was also during a time when Louis Tomlinson and Harry Styles were on tour, and I just HAD to watch all of their shows. No matter if they were in Europe or the US or South America, I was watching. That meant I sometimes got up at three in the night, opened an Instagram live on my tablet and X on my phone and enjoyed the show with thousands of others who couldn’t attend. After the show, which I knew by hard after the fourth time, I went back to bed and then slept till noon. When it was my time to see Louis, I got in my car and drove six hours to Cologne where I cued in line for fifteen hours, covered in a thick blanket to shield me from the early April cold. I ate energy bars and pretzels, drank liquid meals made for athletes and read fanfictions on my phone. The anticipation for the concert had been built for over a year and the release was otherworldly. I cried during the concert because I was so happy, and I cried even more after because it was over and I had nothing to look forward to. In music fandoms this is called post-concert depression and I can tell you, it does not mix well with regular depression.
I came home from that show to my dark, cold, empty apartment and the only reason I had to keep going was gone. The concert had been my silver lining and when the spotlights on stage went dark, the last flicker of hope was snuffed.
I had finished my bachelor thesis and I went to the concert I had dreamed of going to and until I would start my internship in August, I had nothing to do. I was utterly bored, also because my songwriting came to a halt. I had written and sung everything I wanted to say, I had posted the music on YouTube and now I was done with it. Feeling useless and bored I decided to go look for a part-time job, something to bridge the gap between May and August and I did the worst thing possible. I began working night shifts.
“Little Sara, you're a diamond in the rough
And I know that you don't hear this all enough
And I'm sure that's why your wrists have tons of cuts
And I'm sure that's why you think you're not enough
On your nineteenth birthday you thought that you were done
Tons of people in your home, but it only felt like one
'Cause your brain can only think about the waiting loaded gun”
In late April of 2022 I had a job interview with our local newspaper and because as a child I have already had a paper route, it was not difficult to secure the job. My responsibility was to deliver the daily newspaper to every subscriber before six o’clock in the morning. I was assigned a route in my village, got a little cart to put the papers in an was sent on my way. At first I was glad to have a job. I had felt guilty to just sit at home while my mum paid for most of my stuff. I was also glad it was a job that didn’t involve people. I could just pop on my headphones and walk the familiar streets in my village. The route took me around two hours to complete as it was in the hilliest area of my village. Paired with the full cart of newspapers the route was actually quite exhausting, plus it rained a lot that spring. But at least I had something to do.
Before going out on my own, I had a practice run with married couple who delivered papers in another village. They told me their routine which was to go to bed at eight and then wake up at half past three to go to work. It gave them their recommended hours of sleep without messing too much with their bio rhythm. I tried that method for a couple of days, but my body was not used to going to bed early and I could never sleep before twelve, which resulted in me having three hours of sleep. I developed my own routine which was not to go to bed at all. I would watch TV, eat cereal, and be on my phone until it was time for work at around three am. At five am I would fall into bed to get my eight to nine hours of sleep. Even though I slept more than enough like this, I was constantly tired. It was really hard for my body to get used to the new sleeping schedule and there were often times, when I was bone tired at five am but just could not sleep with the birds singing in front of my window and the sun rising.
“But your friends are all still here, so pretend you're having fun
All your friends they wanna drink 'cause it's your birthday
But you've been drinking straight probably since last Thursday
Drinking is the only thing that makes you feel just okay
It keeps the trigger finger off the trigger and at bay”
The night shift was also really limiting my options to see other people. I was either sleeping, tired, or working and meeting with my sister or friends or even seeing my family became an even bigger obstacle than my depression had previously posed. I had created my own isolation.
Now that my body was tired from being depressed and from being tired in a normal way I stopped taking St. John’s Wort. I felt a bit better than the year before and so I thought the pills had done their job. That it was a bad idea to stop taking the pills right when I started a very lonely job did not occur to me. I was so sick of being sick, I declared myself healed and the pills superfluous. It’s easy to say all of this in hindsight but I was really sure then, that I was on a better path. An internship lined up, my own money to spend however I wanted, my bachelor thesis submitted and a new Harry Styles album coming out soon.
To go off any mood-altering pill, especially anti-depressants, from one day to the other, can have harsh consequences from nausea, to insomnia, dizziness, sadness, anxiety, and so on. But I thought, since St. John’s Wort is mostly natural, there was no harm to discontinue the pills. While I luckily had no physical ramification from the drastic withdrawal, the absence of the reuptake inhibitor was like a party invitation for my depression. It came back with a fanfare, a green polka dot party hat, and the willingness to take over my brain.
“Your mind can only think about the things it shouldn't
Your brain is filled with thoughts of wishing that ya didn't
Little Sarah, perk your ears up try to listen
But she can't hear a sound because she's locked in a prison”
The only thing I liked about my new job was that I didn’t have to talk to anyone and that I could listen to music the whole time. I used the time I was delivering the newspapers to discover new albums and artists, and the quiet nighttime paired with the starry sky, gave every song something ethereal. Some nights I also liked to listen to albums I haven’t listen to in a while, from my childhood or early teens. But I have also created a playlist filled with songs that spoke to another mood. The nights when I was skipping along the street with new music fueling my body were rare. More often I was crawling up the hills, listening to a playlist I curated and called “Maybe This Is Not the Place”. A playlist I created for nights when the demons won. When being alive didn’t seem possible anymore. When earth maybe wasn’t the place for me anymore. It consisted of sad songs where the singers were screaming their lungs out, the notes filled with pain, the silences with suffering. I had Luke Hemming’s whole When Facing the Things We Turn Away From album on there, songs like “Hold On” by Chord Overstreet which is about a lover not being able to say goodbye to their partner who wants to leave this world, or Billie Eilish’s “Lovely” that I heard a lot at the beginning of my depression, because when she sings “Hello, welcome home,” I always imagined my depression welcoming me home into its dark, cavernous hug. I also included Phoebe Bridgers cover of “That Funny Feeling”. The song was originally written by Bo Burnham for his Netflix special Inside. The show is a mixture of a comedy set and a self-aware look at the pandemic and the isolation we all felt, filled with songs that dominated social media after its release. “That Funny Feeling” specifically is filled with remarks at current trends and events and the juxtaposition of everything that is wrong with our society. And every time Phoebe Bridgers whispered in my ear “The quiet comprehending of the ending of it all”, I felt something inside my heart twitch.
But why did I do that? Why purposefully make me sadder? Because the songs were comforting and melancholic. Oftentimes, and especially while I was taking St. John’s Wort, it wasn’t the sadness that dragged me down but the absence of happiness. The absence of all harmonious feelings. The numbness was sometimes so excruciating that I made myself cry with those songs to at least feel something. They were gut-wrenching and heartbreaking and so relatable that for three to four minutes I was less alone.
“She can barely see the pavement, she can barely read the signs
People think she's complicated but never wanna look inside
'Cause she's a little too R-rated and they're a little too damn blind
She's just looking for her angels, but they're a little hard to find”
My mother once asked me if my depression was getting to a point where I wanted to commit suicide. The word scared me. It felt tainted with shame and societies prejudices, so I answered no. I wasn’t thinking about it. I sometimes wanted the pain to end but killing myself hadn’t crossed my mind. That’s what I told her. I lied. Not just to her but to myself. I had often thought about ending it because the pain began to feel unbearable. All I wanted was peace and the only place that offers lasting peace is death.
The first time the thought crossed my mind was in late 2021. I had miscalculated my study schedule the semester before and realized I was missing five credits. I was so disappointed in myself and so angry that I overlooked that detail. I thought I could begin my bachelor thesis that semester and instead I had to push back everything once again. Combined with the courses I had to push back because of covid and the cancelled semester abroad I would be looking at a total of nine semesters for a degree that had a scheduled duration of six semester. I saw my future crumble before my eyes. What company would ever take someone who needed four and a half years for a degree and then not even excel at it?
I shut my laptop after I realized my mistake and went on a walk to clear my head. Tears were welling up in my eyes and the wind of early autumn was lashing my hair in my face. I walked to the edge of my town and there I sat down on a bench to think. The bench stood in front of a field, the forest in my back, and in the middle of the field stood a transmission tower. I thought of my doomed future, my destitute present and stared at the transmission tower until all I could think of was climbing that tower and throwing myself off it. Maybe I could even reach the high-tension power line and make it quick. The tears didn’t fall that day because it was hypothetical thought. A part of me wanted to do it but another was aware that someone would find me and report it to my parents. That they would have to identify me and grieve their oldest daughter. But that day the door to suicidal thoughts was opened and over the months I nudged it opened more and more. A free passage to the otherworld.
I have never spent much time thinking of suicide when I was younger. Why should a healthy person do that? For example, in school we once were able to choose the next subject we would be discussing in religious studies, and we had a choice between suicide and gay marriage. In that damn classroom filled with thirty students I was the only one who voted for gay marriage. So, we talked about suicide. How the church frowns upon it and about the assisted suicide that was legal in Switzerland but not in Germany. I didn’t feel very comfortable with that topic, but I couldn’t put my finger on why. A few years later when the TV series “13 Reasons Why” was making headlines, I watched it as well, but I didn’t like it and skipped the last episode all together. I didn’t want to see Hannah die and I disliked the whole dark aesthetic of the show. Suicide had always scared me, even saying the word made something inside me cringe. And then suddenly I was where I never thought I would be, and it was all I could think about.
“Little Sara, you've been skipping out in class
And any minute now your friends are gonna ask
Why the hell you're always acting sorta sad
Why the hell your weed just never seems to last
But the truth is you don't wanna let your secret out
'Cause they think it's wrong for you to take a different route
All except your mom too bad that she's just not around”
In the night from the thirteenth to the fourteenth of May I put the “Maybe This Is Not the Place” playlist on shuffle right as I left my house. I have felt miserable the whole day, filling my hours with TikTok and Netflix. Dragging my body to work was hard and I pulled the cart behind me like all the dead weight I have been carrying around for too long had come to life. I had delivered the first paper, when I walked up the first hill. Normally all houses were still, the lights were out, and the curtains drawn but that night light spilled from one window onto the street. The illuminated room must have been a living room judging by the size of it. It was a rather old building and inside were exposed beams, the first thing I saw when I raised my head to follow the light with my gaze. I looked at the beams and thought, “If I had beams like that in my living room, I would hang myself”. Immediately tears came to my eyes as I was surprised by force of my thought yet not by the thought itself. Since that time by the transmission tower, suicidal ideation clung to me like a limpet.
I haven’t had a concrete plan to kill myself but most days I just wanted the pain to stop and when you’re so sick and so tired, there doesn’t seem to be a different path out. Death seemed like a soothing end to an agonizing existence. I found comfort in the knowledge, that death was always an option but at the same time I was terrified of myself. Would I really do it? Could I do it?
The more I sank into my hole, the more my TikTok algorithm realized that I was struggling. You oftentimes see people on social media posting about how well the algorithm knows them and mine wasn’t any different. It realized that I didn’t skip sad videos, that I listened to depressing songs longer and that I liked videos tagged with hashtags like #depression, #paintok or even #relatable. Social media can suck you into a vortex of sad videos until you think that is all that there is to it. To life. Those videos were mostly filmed by nighttime, showing a rainy street or a thunderstorm, underlaid with an instrumental track in minor key and a small text sat in the middle of the shot reading: “I’m still alive because I don’t want my parents to find their dead child” or “Every time I think things are getting better, they are getting worse”. Once you are in that dark social media rabbit hole, more and more videos will be recommended for you until all the content you consume is either glorifying depression or suicide.
“And don't get me wrong those words you've tried to get them out
But their views been skewed by their plastic news from their plasma tubes
So they won't fit in your shoes
Except for Sunday blues, but you got Monday blues
You got Tuesday blues, damn every day ya might lose”
While the tears streamed down my face that one night, I thought about those videos. I had watched some throughout the day when they washed up on my For You Page. I thought about how deep I had fallen and about how I didn’t want to think those thoughts anymore. They were nagging at me, and I was too tired to keep going when all I wanted was to lie still. I just wanted to be normal, walk along the street, see exposed beams in a living room and not think about hanging myself there. I cried myself into a fit, silently delivering papers as the demons in my head won. How would I ever be able to stop them? My lungs hurt from walking up the hill while crying, my head ached from the grimaces you do when you cry, my throat contracted from the lump that grew bigger and bigger. But I couldn’t stop crying and I didn’t want to stop crying because it was all I could do. So, when I took a quick break to catch my breath, I unlocked my phone and put the song “Sara” by We Three into the queue. The song opens with a heavy sigh before the lead singer tells the story of Sara in a melodious parlando. Sara is a young girl with cuts on her arms celebrating her birthday with her friends while all she can think about is the loaded gun in her bedroom. In the chorus he sings: “She can barely see the pavement, she can barely read the signs. People think she’s complicated but never wanna look inside” and while I dragged my body further up the hill, I too couldn’t see the pavement through my tears. I put the song on repeat and listened to it for the rest of my route, crying harder with each time. During the last verse, Sara couldn’t think of even two or three reasons to stay, so she sits down to write her suicide letter before cutting her wrists. I stuffed tear-stained newspapers into tiny slots and desperately wanted to think about two or three reasons why I was glad, why I was happy or why I should stay. I couldn’t find a single one. Maybe it was because I was listening to that song for more than an hour but when I returned home, exhausted but not nearly cried out, I wrote my own suicide note.
“All your friends they wanna smoke 'cause it's a Friday
But you've been smoking straight probably since last Sunday
I know you know you shouldn't say that you are okay
But you still look 'em in the eye and lie then go to use your ashtray”
I went to bed that early morning of May 14th, my mother’s birthday, and typed out how I felt. My fingers were whizzing over the keyboard as I described the constant pain I was in, the numbness that turned me indifferent towards everything, that I no longer saw a way out. I began typing just to get the feelings out of my head but when I finished I saw that what I had written was a suicide note. I threw my phone on the ground and wept into my pillow. I was so scared of who I had become, I could not trust myself anymore. I knew that if I didn’t do something right now to get me out of that headspace, I would not survive. I went online and searched for mental health hotlines, but I was hoarse from all the crying and too anxious to actually call someone. In that moment I would have actually gone to my mother, to let her comfort me and confess my ‘weakness’ to her but she was on vacation. The only other person I could go to, was my sister but she was asleep upstairs, and I didn’t want to burden her. I was her big sister. I was supposed to care for her, be there for her, not the other way around. And the thought of overwhelming her by waking her up seemed too selfish. So I sat it out. I wept until I fell asleep, hurting, and empty.
“Little Sarah, last night you got it bad
In that moment you could barely even add up two or three reasons why you're glad
And I guess that's why you grabbed your pen and pad
It was 6:14 and you could barely even read
All the words you'd written down of why it was time for you to leave
Your phone was on the ground and you could barely hear it ring
Couldn't even hear a sound, couldn't feel a single thing”
The next morning, or rather afternoon, when I woke up, I washed my face with cold water. It was still red and blotchy and then I went into the kitchen to prepare for that night. It was the night of the 2022 Eurovision Song Contest and I had planned a get-together with my sister and two of our friends. We all had drawn a region in Europe and were supposed to bring food from that region. Since I had northern Europe, I stood in the kitchen preparing salmon-cucumber sticks, tea-time sandwiches and meatballs. I pushed away all thoughts about the previous night, focusing only on the task at hand. That evening, while we watched the ESC and ate food from all around Europe, I don’t think any of my friends noticed that just the night before I wanted to kill myself if only I had known how to.
When the show was over and my friends left, I went to work, not listening to my sad playlist, not listening to “Sara”, and just did my work with a stony face and an empty heart. I continued to do that job for another two weeks. Then I had to quit, or I would have abandoned my cart and walked into the woods to disappear forever. Some nights I was barely able to walk, that’s how weak I was. Plus the sleep schedule did not work for me and I felt worse than I had ever before. I got a doctor’s notice and got out of my contract quickly so the crying girl stalking the streets of the village in the middle of the night was no more. For months after, I couldn’t walk my paper route without breaking into tears because it reminded me too much of that dark night when the pain seemed endless, but life didn’t.
“Now, it's 6:15 and you're on your knees, blood is on your sleeves
And your lungs won't breathe, eyes are watering, body's shivering
And you're wondering what is happening”
For months afterwards I was glad to have written the note, so that, should I ever make a split-second decision, I at least had something written down. I carried it with me on my phone for almost two years. Just in case. I used to always think “One day I’ll be brave enough and kill myself” but the real brave act was not to do it. To hang on. To keep fighting. And it was a really long fight. Even after I got better and my mood improved, I didn’t delete the note because it felt like a safety blanket. Something I could fall back onto. Something I could rely on. I was afraid that deleting it might mean that one day I would forget just how bad things could get. But I could never forget and deleting it meant moving on. It was like losing my training wheels. But when I finally deleted it, almost two years later, I had hope. I had managed to get out, what would prevent me from doing it again?
“Now, it's 6:23, and they're on their knees, begging Jesus please
Can you make her breathe
'Cause they finally see what was happening underneath their nose
And underneath your sleeves”